Why You Should Ditch Gmail (And What to Use Instead)

IT & Systems
, , , ,
1

Google reads your email. Not a person at Google. The system itself. Every message, scanned and indexed.

Gmail is free because you are the product. Every email you send and receive is analyzed for advertising data. Google knows what you buy, where you travel, who you talk to, what bills you pay, and when your subscriptions renew. All of it fed into a profile that advertisers pay to target.

I switched away from Gmail ten years ago. My email is now end-to-end encrypted, hosted in a country with strong privacy laws, and completely outside Google’s reach. The transition took a weekend and I have not looked back.

What’s Wrong with Gmail

  • All mail is scanned. Google’s systems parse the content of every message to build your advertising profile.
  • Data is stored in the US. Subject to US law, government requests, and national security letters that prevent the provider from telling you about the request.
  • No end-to-end encryption. Google holds the keys. If they’re compelled to hand over your email, they can.
  • Account locks with no recourse. Google can disable your account with no warning and no human to appeal to. If your entire digital life runs through Gmail, that’s a single point of failure.

This is not about having something to hide. It’s about having something to protect.

What to Use Instead

Proton Mail is what I use and recommend. It’s based in Switzerland, end-to-end encrypted by default between Proton users, and protected by Swiss privacy laws. They cannot read your email even if they wanted to, because they do not hold the encryption keys.

Other solid options:

  • Tuta (formerly Tutanota) Based in Germany. End-to-end encrypted. Similar to Proton in approach.
  • Fastmail Based in Australia. Not end-to-end encrypted, but privacy-respecting and not ad-funded. Good if you want premium email without the encryption focus.
  • Self-hosted (Mail-in-a-Box, Mailcow) Full control, but managing your own email server is a serious time commitment. Deliverability alone is a part-time job.

For most people, Proton Mail hits the right balance of privacy, usability, and reliability.

Custom Domain on Proton

If you own a domain (and you should for anything professional), you can use it with Proton Mail. This means your email address is you@yourdomain.com instead of you@proton.me. If you ever switch providers, the address stays with you because you own the domain.

Setup takes about 15 minutes:

  1. Sign up for a Proton Mail paid plan (custom domains require the Mail Plus plan or higher)
  2. Add your domain in the Proton dashboard
  3. Update your DNS records (MX, SPF, DKIM, DMARC) at your domain registrar. I use Namecheap but any registrar works, including Cloudflare, Porkbun, or wherever you already have your domain
  4. Verify the domain in Proton
  5. Create your address and start receiving mail

Proton walks you through each DNS record with exact values to paste. You do not need to understand DNS to do this.

Migrating Without Losing Everything

The biggest fear with switching email is losing your history or missing messages during the transition. Here’s how to handle it:

  1. Set up forwarding on Gmail to your new address. Every new message lands in both inboxes during the transition.
  2. Import your old mail using Proton’s Easy Switch tool. It copies your entire Gmail archive into Proton, folders and all.
  3. Update your accounts one at a time. Start with the important ones: banking, insurance, work, subscriptions. Change the email on each account to your new address.
  4. Keep Gmail forwarding active for 3-6 months. This catches anything you missed. Once nothing new comes in for a while, you’re fully moved.
  5. Delete or archive your Gmail account once you’re satisfied everything is migrated.

What About the Calendar and Drive?

If you’re switching from Gmail, you’re probably also using Google Calendar and Google Drive. Proton offers both:

  • Proton Calendar End-to-end encrypted, syncs across devices, imports ICS files from Google.
  • Proton Drive End-to-end encrypted cloud storage. Not as feature-rich as Google Drive yet, but solid for document storage and sharing.

You do not have to switch everything at once. Start with email. Move the rest when you’re ready.

What It Costs

Proton Mail has a free tier (one address, 1GB storage). For a custom domain and more storage, the paid plans start at around $4/month. That’s less than most people spend on coffee in a day, for email that nobody is mining for ad data.

Links

Join the Conversation

This post takes a clear position, but everything in it is backed by sources linked throughout. Read them, check them, and draw your own conclusions.

Have you already made the switch? Tell us what you moved to and whether you regret it. Still on Gmail and not convinced? Say why. If you’re on the fence and have a specific concern holding you back, ask it below and I or someone else here will likely have an answer.

This is one of those topics where real-world experience from other people is more useful than any guide.